Trademark Introduction for Indies
With the on-going Tim Langdell trademarking discussions this seems a good time to post some information about trademarks.
UK lawyer Alex Chapman (Sheridans) represents a number of independent developers and is representing Mobigames in their trademark dispute with Edge Games (*cough* this link is not entirely accurate but was better than linking to the real site!). He has kindly posted some information which should answer many of the common questions people have over trademark uses, rights and registration. Note that this is a UK/EU perspective and laws do vary across territories.
1. A trade mark is anything that identifies the goods and services of a business or distinguishes them from those of another.
2. A registered trade mark gives statutory protection and an effective monopoly in respect of that mark for the goods or services it is registered for AND for similar marks with the same or similar goods where there is a likelihood of confusion. Well known registered trade marks have additional protection if used by others for different goods or services to those for which they are registered if that use takes unfair advantage of or is detrimental to the repute of the well known registered mark.
3. Marks that are not registered have common law protection through passing off – which occurs if a third party uses a trading name, style or get up that misrepresents a connection or association with the owner of goodwill in a business undertaken under or by reference to that trading name, style or get up and in doing so causes damage to the owner. That damage includes lost revenue that it would have received had the “infringer” entered into a licence agreement with the owner.
4. Certain trade marks can’t be registered and can’t be said to have sufficient goodwill for passing off. These include geographical indications, signs that designate the nature or intended use of the goods or services or are otherwise devoid of distinctive character and incapable of distinguishing the goods and services of one entity from those of another. For example Egg for eggs or Cake for cakes is a NO but Egg for financial services and Cake for PR is a YES.
5. Marks that are otherwise devoid of distinctive character can however be registered and can have goodwill in them if they become distinctive through the use made of them.
6. If you don’t use a registered trade mark for a continuing period of 5 years it becomes liable to be revoked.
7. If you don’t enforce your rights as a trade mark owner and don’t object to someone else’s use of your mark you can be considered to have acquiesced and lose the right to enforce – but this is more complex than it sounds.
8. You should apply to register your key brands as registered trade marks [contact Alex Chapman directly for more information].
9. If you threaten someone with a registered trade mark infringement action without good grounds then you can be liable to pay damages for “groundless threats”.
10. It is a criminal offence to say a trade mark is registered when it isn’t.
11. Trade mark registration is territorial though a single European application can be made covering all countries of the EU.
12. Trade Marks are registered in respect of classes of goods and services. There are 45 different classes and when making an application you need to draft an appropriate specification in each class.
13. Making an application also gives 6 months priority in other territories so that additional applications can be made in other territories and back dated in that time.
14. A registration would last 10 years but can be renewed at that time.
15. Trade Mark registration is by far the best way to protect your brand but understanding trade marks is also important so that you don’t infringe someone else’s.
I’d like to thank Alex for his help with this post. Trademark, Patent and Copyright law is a complex business and I suggest that professional queries should be directed to Sheridans or another suitable IP specialist.
If you’re an independent developer then I’m happy to recommend Alex Chapman for your IP queries and Publishing/Distribution contracts (he didn’t pay me to say this but he’s definitely bought me a drink or two in his time!).
Finally, please do mention this blog if contacting Alex or Sheridans – that way we’ll be able to get some more legal advice for indies on here!
Tags: chapman, legal, sheridans, trade mark, trademarks
Developers take on Tim ‘Trademark Troll’ Langdell
I’m not the only one ranting this week. Developers (including myself) from my favourite developer forum, The Chaos Engine, have just issued a statement regarding the Tim Langdell vs Mobigames ‘Edge’ trademark dispute. You can read Develop’s summary of TCE’s press release here. TIGSource have also come out strongly against Tim’s actions and are even [...]
Train2Game Reply
I had an interesting phone call this afternoon from Clive Roberts, responsible for Train2Game. I did some work for Clive many years ago so I did half expect this – I was not a random blog author to him.
We had quite an amicable chat. Clive was at pains to point out that the Study Guide [...]
The Poor Marketing of Train2Game
I’ve just returned from Develop and I’m in such a stomping rage that I’m actually going to update my blog rather than my Twitter feed.
I better preface the rest of this post by saying that I 100% back the work by the likes of TIGA and Skillset to improve the education of those entering the [...]
BadMovieClub – The First Twitter Flash Mob
On 13th Feb 2009, several thousand people watched the same ‘bad’ film at exactly the same time and shared their collective ‘disappointment’ via Twitter. I was one of those people.
A few days ago I received a message from a friend on Twitter; join #badmovieclub it said. Turns out it was spawned from Graham Linehan’s off [...]
Cletus, Dyson Nominated for IGF Award
Firstly I want to wish everyone a Happy New Year. I have a few articles planned out which have been delayed slightly for reasons I’ll go into in the near future, but they will be forthcoming.
Secondly, I’m immensely proud to say that Cletus Clay has been nominated for the IGF Excellence in Visual Arts award. [...]
Peggle – Why is it fun?
You know how there are some games people can never agree on? One of those is Peggle. I really don’t like it.
Don’t get me wrong, I think it’s a beautifully crafted project and it’s about as polished as you get. The visuals are great, the interface super-simple, and audio just what was needed. It’s just [...]
Will Casual Eat Itself in 2009?
Grubby Games have just released My Tribe, their take on the casual sim genre that was lead by the surprise hit Virtual Villagers. I’m a big fan of Grubby’s work, especially the almighty Fizzball, and this game looks like another decent effort with some good reviews appearing.
Still, I’m a little bothered about the space they [...]
Digg it up for Cletus Clay on PC and XBLA
Today I can reveal that Cletus Clay is going to appear on both PC and Xbox LIVE Arcade platforms!
We’ve also got a new blog post revealing why Anthony chose to work with clay, as well as a little more about the game itself, complete with one of our early images.
Please read for the blog post [...]
Cletus Clay blog live on TunaSnax
To those who were wondering, I am still alive – just! I’m hard at work hammering out our indie title, which you can now find blogged on TunaSnax.
I’m very pleased to say that we’re working with Anthony Flack to create his long awaited follow-up to Platypus (download it here), Cletus Clay. To say the least, [...]
